None of this helped. No matter how hard he tried, J remained slow to form letters, had trouble with manipulation of writing implements (and scissors), complained of fatigue and was, in the end, completely turned off handwriting. As I was (and still am) a stationery collector with pens aplenty, we sought out all manner of different styles of pen and pencil. Every type of pencil grip was trialled, we have writing slopes, cut out windows to reduce the area he has to write in, coloured note pads (crossbow education have a great range), paper with raised lines, squared pads, shaded writing books, the list is endless. He tried short pencils (as this 'forces' a tripod grip), fat pens (to reduce strain) and textured pencils (so he could feel them better). Fat, light pens with a smooth writing action are favoured - so the Staedtler Mechanical pencil
We supplied the school with an Alphasmart NEO for times when it was more important to get J's ideas down on paper than for him to use handwriting. Again, none of it helped. Even now, at 12, letters still have to be talked about - where does a "guh" go - and even his own name he cannot reliably write correctly.
When he was first out of school we discussed a programme of letter formation with his Occupational Therapist. She had found out that he didn't realise the space that each letter 'ought' to take up - that is there are ascenders, descenders and letters with both! So, using a subject that interested him at the time, we linked each letter to a part of a volcano - those with ascenders went to the ash cloud, descenders the magma chamber and the rest were the cone. This, together with doing a daily exercise using the Handwriting Without Tears programme we reinforced the idea of how letters are formed, where they 'go' and how they should look... it's a multi-sensory approach (although we had to amend it slightly as J can't bear the sound/feel of chalk but that's another story).
I guess there is no end to this post as J still struggles to write, has very low stamina and is poor at forming words. He uses technology as much as he can. Produces mindmaps to encapsulate his thoughts and ideas and will dictate to me should he feel that he has more to say.
If you work with a child like J, please consider just how incredibly hard it is for them. Our experience tells us they are not "being difficult" or "wasting time". They are struggling to achieve. Have you explained it VERY clearly to them? Do they 'get' what you are asking them to do? Are you sure? Adding to their workload with additional tasks or insisting on task completion (whilst others go out to play) is not constructive. Give them quick ways to do things, provide them with printouts and encourage them to love putting pen to paper. Don't turn them off by putting up unattainable barriers. Allow them to express themselves in different ways, be innovative, use smaller sheets of paper, reduce the amount they are expected to deliver and, hopefully, with time the HAND writing will follow (if they are able). But if they're not, so what? When was the last time you put pen to paper? Most things these days are done online, electronically or via text so give those skills and they'll be well away.
Great post, very thought provoking.
ReplyDeleteThanks! It's taken long enough to get round to posting it... and there was a 'gap' in my busyness that allowed me the time ;-)
ReplyDelete